Pilar Guarné: sobriety and exuberance



The Con spirito series concluded on Friday, October 23, with a performance by pianist Pilar Guarné, who presented a recital entitled "Polyhedral Classicism." The program featured three composers who were in Vienna between 1781 and 1782.

The composer Marianne von Martinez (Vienna, 1744-1812), of Spanish (grandfather) and Italian (father) descent, achieved great acclaim in her time despite professional limitations imposed by her gender. Her surviving compositions include oratorios, cantatas, masses, arias, motets, sonatas, keyboard concertos, and a symphony.

The Sonata in E major for keyboard dates from approximately 1763 and was most likely written for the harpsichord or the Tangentenflügel. It is important to note that Andreas Stein's pianos, which would later become known as the Viennese piano mechanism, were still in the experimental stage. Mozart himself did not encounter Stein's pianos until 1777. Despite the influence of Haydn, Marianne's first keyboard teacher, the sonata displays a distinctly Italian style. There are moments when it seems as if we are listening to Scarlatti. Marianna's tutelage was in the hands of the poet Metastasio, a close friend of the family, and in Vienna, much to Mozart's chagrin, the Italians largely dominated the market. Mozart, twelve years her junior, was part of Marianna's musical circle and recognized her musical talent, even playing four-hands with her.

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart wrote the Fantasia in D minor, K. 397, in 1782, a period when he had already played Stein's pianos and owned an Anton Walter. The sound of this work is distinctly pianistic, free, as is typical of a fantasia, and narrative in nature. The key of D minor in Mozart is usually associated with emotional intensity, drama, and sorrow (Requiem, Don Giovanni, Piano Concerto No. 20...). But this fantasy opens the door to optimism by ending in D major. The manuscript was lost, and the work remained unfinished; the final bars were written by August Eberhard Müller (1767-1817), a composer who contributed to the spread of Viennese Classicism, and therefore we don't really know how Mozart envisioned it. The brevity of the ending suggests that it would have been longer. It is a work highly appreciated by pianists and audiences alike.

In the third position on the program, Pilar Guarné presents a bold and interesting proposal. She brings together three German dances by Mozart and three Monferrinas by Clementi in an alternating and continuous dialogue, linked by brief transitions written by herself that seamlessly connect them. The result is a work full of discursive logic, engaging and joyful, which drew sincere applause from the audience. The German Dances and the Monferrinas come respectively from the folk dances of southern Germany (Bavaria) and northern Italy (Monferrato) and are a clear example of compositions intended for leisure, but also proof of the folk roots of classical music.

In the second part of the concert, Guarné offered us two late sonatas by Mozart and Clementi, works of considerable size that bring together the most significant characteristics of each composer.

The Sonata in B-flat major, K. 570, from 1789, is the penultimate of Mozart's solo piano sonatas and an example of his idiomatic and refined writing. The opening Allegro is in the form of a classical sonata, with clean writing that alternates delicate melodic dialogues between both hands with homophonic moments reminiscent of operatic writing. The second movement is a reflective Adagio in rondo form, with inspired melodies, register changes, and an overall harmonic structure (E-flat major, C minor, A-flat major) that presents a varied yet tranquil landscape. Pilar Guarné's interpretation of this movement was particularly inspired. The sonata concludes with a Haydnesque Allegretto rondo, featuring some strikingly chromatic passages.

Clementi's Op. 50 Sonatas close his official catalogue, although they are not the last works he wrote. They were possibly already planned as a second book of the Op. 40 Sonatas of 1804 and offered to the publisher Härtel in 1809. The metronome markings, dated after 1815, suggest that Clementi continued working on them between that year and 1821, when they were published simultaneously in Paris, Leipzig, and Vienna.

The first movement of the second sonata is an Allegro non troppo ma con energia characterized by passion and elegance. The movement is full of expressive markings, unexpected modulations, and brilliant passages of great pianism. Here, Pilar Guarné let loose and provoked a spontaneous burst of applause from an audience that is usually very reserved, waiting for the end of the pieces. The second movement, Adagio con espressione, is a beautiful melody of introspective character and subtle polyphonic accompaniment that the pianist recited with delicacy and inspiration. The polyphonic music, which the pianist recited with subtlety and inspiration, was a striking feature. The final movement, Allegro con Fuoco, ma non troppo Presto, is a sonata form remarkable for its continuous treatment of the theme motif through a range of modulations, expectant silences, and contrasting passages, all within an extensive, agile, and brilliant development. The grand passion and sonata form recall the extravagance of Beethoven's Appassionata, where nothing seems to be in the place one would expect in a classical sonata. We are faced with an original work, rooted in the Beethovenian style and a precursor to Romanticism.

Pilar Guarné's music and interpretation captivated the audience, who responded with enthusiastic applause. Guarné followed with a delightful Schubert Waltz.

Note: Pilar Guarné studied at the Barcelona Municipal Conservatory when this center was of higher degree, under the chair of the pianist Carme Vilà, from whom she inherited a solid technique and a great knowledge of the Viennese style.

Joan Josep Gutiérrez

LISTEN TO THE FULL RECITAL  https://www.youtube.com/live/s9Z0DPESaiw?si=5SC3-61wpmCDQnAk&t=535