Review of the book "The Zumpe & Buntebart square piano of the Museu de la Música de Barcelona"



On May 9, 2019, the book “The Zumpe & Buntebart square piano of the Museu de la Música de Barcelona” was presented at the Museu de la Música de Barcelona.

This publication aims to provide to the specialists and all people in general one of the most complete and serious studies of the history and meaning of one of the builders that could be considered as the more revolutionary within the context of the history of the piano. The book is coordinated by Pablo Gómez Ábalos, who contributes whit his articles El pianoforte Zumpe from the keyboard. A study of sources, organological and biomechanical and An annotated bibliography of Zumpe and his pianoforteMichael Cole, recognised researcher and constructor of pianofortes and harpsichords, brings the article Johannes Zumpe, Gabriel Buntebart and their small pianoforte in context and the piano restorer, Kerstin Schwarz, describe in detail the restoration in The restoration of the square piano by Johannes Zumpe & Gabriel Buntebart, London 1776, Museu de la Música de Barcelona. The book is introduced by an article by the curator of the museum, Marisa Ruiz Magaldi, which reviews the history of the museum and the origin of the model Zumpe that concerns us in the article The Zumpe & Buntebart square piano (1776) of the Museu de la Música de Barcelona. Finally, Gómez Ábalos elaborates a technical sheet of the different Zumpe pianos mentioned in the book and closes the publication with a specialized bibliography.
The book is presented in a careful edition of 276 pages, in 21 x 21 cm. format, which includes three languages, Catalan, Spanish and English, and black and white illustrations. The publication is edited by the Museum of Music of Barcelona and Documenta Universitaria. An electronic version is available on the page of this publisher.


About the texts, I would like to highlight some details that I consider  specially important. First, it must be said that they are written with clarity and scientific accuracy, both in terms of content and references. It may present some difficulties for the non-specialized reader in piano mechanics issues, since details and lexicon are very specialized in the descriptions. These descriptions, however, are essential to contextualize the Zumpe piano within the evolution of the piano.

An interesting concept that is proposed is the independence of the square piano between the different types of piano, not simply as one of many historical experiments or as a temporary model. The square piano is a differentiated instrument that has its own sound and mechanical characteristics. I want to remember that, from the first experiments of Zumpe in the decade of the 1760s, the square piano evolved in parallel to the grand piano and the upright piano and was made until the end of the 19th century, although sharing technical innovations with the rest of the pianos. One hundred and forty years of existence! The current rescue of the square pianos of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries is recovering for us  some sonorities that had been lost but had been in the minds of many composers.

The idea that the piano deserves a differentiated treatment also is linked with the false theory of the German school derived from Silbermann and exiled in England due to the Seven Years' War, the romantic myth of the "twelve apostles". Zumpe was not a disciple of Silbermann and his piano derives rather from mechanical concepts of his own, closer to the Pantalon and clavichord. The simple action of a jack directly on the hammer base simplifies to the maximum a mechanism that Cristofori, Silbermann and others developed, in which there was an intermediate lever, an escapement and a backcheck. None of this is found in Zumpe's piano which, however, responds with delicacy to the dynamic and articulation demands. With a big difference with the modern piano, of course! The recovery of the escapement and of the intermediate lever, would derive a few decades later in the double action English mechanism that so much success would contribute the pianos of Broadwood, Clementi and others. But this is another business.

Another idea that emerges is the social element of the Zumpe piano. The simplicity and size of his instrument made it relatively cheap and appropriate for the middle classes. It was cheaper than a harpsichord and could be put in a small space. Thus, their social influence was very high and immediately many builders get on board to create one of the most important industries of the turn of the century England. All this corresponds to the social changes of the revolutions and the pre-eminence of the British Empire in the commercial fields of the time.

The restoration of the model of the museum, carried out by Kerstin Schwarz, brings a lot of additional information to the history of this Zumpe and brings to light very interesting details. For example, the analysis of some later modifications indicates that this piano was part of an "organized piano", that is, a piano mounted on a small organ that could sound simultaneously or independently. Other things discovered by the restorer are the interventions and modifications made later to "modernize" the piano. In its restoration, the original features have been recovered to the maximum, taking as a model different specimens from other museums in the world.

In summary, I would say that the reading of this book gives us a broader vision of the history of the piano and the revision of some topics installed in it. A recommended publication for all students of music. The next obligatory activity is to go to the Museum of Music of Barcelona and watch the instrument and listen to it on the occasions when it is played.

Joan Josep Gutiérrez, 2019


The book can be found in specialized bookstores, in the Museum of Music of Barcelona or on the page www.documentauniversitaria.com

El piano de taula Zumpe & Buntebart del Museu de la Música de Barcelona
El piano de mesa Zumpe & Buntebart del Museo de la Música de Barcelona
The Zumpe & Buntebart square piano of the Museu de la Música de Barcelona
Pablo Gómez Ábalos (ed.)